GRA Blogs

Articles by Matthew Gilligan.

Matthew Gilligan

Would Removing Loss Ring-Fencing Help NZ Property Investors?

6667

Key Takeaways

  • Removing ring-fencing would let future rental losses reduce tax on your salary and other income again.
  • Newer, highly geared investors would benefit most; established investors would see little change.
  • If ring-fencing were removed, a $10,000 rental loss on a $100,000 salary would save about $3,300 a year in tax (at a 33% rate).
  • Ring-fenced losses carry forward, but may never be used if a sale isn't taxable and you exit rentals.
  • Investors who own directly or through a look-through company are likely to benefit most.
  • As at November 2026, nothing is law and, in my opinion, removal is unlikely.

If you're a newer investor with high borrowing and a rental property that runs at a loss, removing loss ring-fencing would make a real difference to your cashflow. If you bought years ago and your rents comfortably cover your costs, it would change very little. In 2026, ACT pledged to remove ring-fencing for future rental losses. In my opinion it's the right call, although I think removal is unlikely to happen.

When residential loss ring-fencing was introduced in 2019, I said publicly that it would hurt ordinary mum and dad investors, not wealthy speculators. Seven years on, my view hasn't changed.

What is loss ring-fencing on rental property?

Our tax system taxes income on a net basis. If your business makes a loss, you can usually offset it against your other income. That applies to a café, a farm, a commercial building or a share portfolio held on revenue account.

Residential rental property is the exception. Since the 2019/20 income year, a rental loss has not been able to reduce the tax on your salary, and that was still the case at the time of writing. The loss is set aside and carried forward until your rentals make a profit or a property is sold in a taxable sale.

That treats one asset class differently from every other investment, even though the economics of owning a rental are no different. In my view, the rule was designed to make housing investment less attractive.

For more background, read my earlier articles: Loss ring-fencing questions and Ring-fencing update.

What has ACT proposed for rental losses?

In 2026, ACT pledged to remove ring-fencing for rental losses incurred from the date the policy takes effect. Those losses could then be offset against your other taxable income, as they could before 2019.

If brought into force, this change would cover both existing homes and new builds. Losses already ring-fenced would remain under the current rules, so any losses you've carried forward since 2019 wouldn't be released against your salary.

Who would benefit most if ring-fencing is removed?

Ring-fencing does little to established investors. People who bought years ago, carry modest debt and collect rents well above their costs rarely make a loss, so the rule barely touches them.

The people it hurts are newer investors. They're salary earners with one or two properties, high borrowing and a weekly top-up from their own pocket. They're building long-term security for their families, and they carry the cashflow strain.

Take someone on a $100,000 salary with a $10,000 rental loss. Before 2019, they would have been taxed as if they earned $90,000, which at a 33% marginal tax rate is worth about $3,300 a year in cash. Under ring-fencing, that $3,300 waits until some uncertain future year, while the investor still covers the shortfall every week.

The rule favours those who are already established and penalises those trying to get started.

Taxable incomeTax rateTax saved each year
on a $10,000 rental loss
without ring-fencing
Tax saved each year
with ring-fencing
Up to $15,60010.5%$1,050$0 (loss carried forward)
$15,601 to $53,50017.5%$1,750$0 (loss carried forward)
$53,501 to $78,10030%$3,000$0 (loss carried forward)
$78,101 to $180,00033%$3,300$0 (loss carried forward)
Over $180,00039%$3,900$0 (loss carried forward)

Figures assume the whole $10,000 loss falls within one tax bracket. Tax rates and thresholds as at November 2026.

Can you lose ring-fenced rental losses?

Usually not, but it can happen. Ring-fencing is designed to delay deductions rather than remove them. The losses are real expenses such as interest, rates, insurance and maintenance. They carry forward and are used when your residential rentals make a profit, or when you sell a residential property and the sale is taxable, for example under the bright-line test.

The catch is a sale that isn't taxable. Selling a rental doesn't automatically release its losses. If the sale falls outside the bright-line test and the other land sale rules, the losses stay ring-fenced. You can still use them against income from another residential rental you own, now or in the future, but if you leave residential property investment for good, they may never be used.

Removing ring-fencing would simply recognise genuine costs in the year they're incurred, as happens everywhere else in the tax system. The cost to the Crown is largely one of timing.

How would removing ring-fencing affect rental supply?

New Zealand needs more rental homes, and private investors provide most of them. A rule that makes a rental harder to fund in its early years, when costs are highest, discourages the investment we need. Removing it would improve the cashflow on rental stock, including new builds, and make property investment more attractive.

Does it matter if you own your rental in a trust, company or LTC?

Yes. How you hold your property will affect whether you benefit if loss ring-fencing is removed. Investors who own directly or through a look-through company are likely to benefit most, because losses can flow through to their personal income.

Rentals held in a trust or an ordinary company need a closer look. Losses in those entities generally stay inside the entity rather than reducing your personal tax, so the change may help less. Your ownership structure should be driven by things like asset protection and estate planning, not by this one rule.

Will loss ring-fencing actually be removed?

When this article was written (November 2026), coalition negotiations were still underway and nothing was law. Removing loss ring-fencing would give welcome relief to the investors who have carried the weight of the 2019 rules, and would move property back towards being taxed like any other investment.

I'd like to see it happen, but I'm not expecting it. The other parties in any potential coalition will not be on board with this, and I do not think it will be a bottom line for ACT. So my prediction is that it more likely ends up a sacrificial concession during negotiations.

What should property investors do about loss ring-fencing?

If ring-fencing stays, keep good records of the losses you carry forward. They can be used when your rentals become profitable or a property is sold in a taxable sale. If you're thinking of selling your last rental, check the tax position first, because losses on a non-taxable sale stay ring-fenced.

There's no need to change anything until the outcome is clear. Tax rules can change, so check the current position before you act.

Wondering what removing, or keeping, loss ring-fencing could mean for your portfolio or structure? Request a meeting or call us on +64 9 522 7955. If you're already a client, talk to your Client Services Manager.

FAQ

What is loss ring-fencing in NZ?

Loss ring-fencing stops losses from residential rental property being offset against other income, such as your salary. It has applied since the 2019/20 income year and was still in force in November 2026. The losses are carried forward and used against future residential rental income or a taxable sale.

Can I offset rental losses against my salary in NZ?

Not while ring-fencing applies. As at November 2026, rental losses can't reduce the tax on your salary. ACT pledged in 2026 to change this for future losses, but it hadn't become law, so check the current rules before relying on this.

Is loss ring-fencing being removed in NZ?

In 2026, ACT pledged to remove ring-fencing for rental losses incurred after the policy takes effect, for both existing homes and new builds. At the time of writing (November 2026), coalition negotiations were still underway, so it wasn't known whether the policy would go ahead.

What happens to my ring-fenced losses if the rules change?

Under ACT's 2026 proposal, losses already ring-fenced would stay under the current rules. You would still carry them forward and use them against future rental profits or a taxable sale.

What happens to ring-fenced losses when you sell a rental property?

It depends on whether the sale is taxable. If it is, for example under the bright-line test, your ring-fenced losses can reduce the taxable gain. If the sale isn't taxable, the losses stay ring-fenced. They can only be used against future residential rental income or a future taxable sale of residential property, so if you don't own another rental, they may never be used.

Does loss ring-fencing apply to new builds?

Yes. As at November 2026, ring-fencing applies to new builds as well as existing homes. ACT's 2026 proposal would remove it for both.

Does loss ring-fencing apply to trusts and companies?

Yes, ring-fencing applies to most owners, including trusts and companies. If the rules were removed, owners holding property directly or through a look-through company are likely to benefit most, because losses can flow through to their personal income.

Matthew Gilligan
signed
Matthew Gilligan
Managing Director and Property Services Partner
© Gilligan Rowe & Associates LP

Did you like this article? Subscribe to our newsletter to receive tips, updates and useful information to help you protect your assets and grow your net worth. We're expert accountants providing expert advice to clients in NZ and around the world.

Disclaimer: This article is intended to provide only a summary of the issues associated with the topics covered. It does not purport to be comprehensive nor to provide specific advice. No person should act in reliance on any statement contained within this article without first obtaining specific professional advice. If you require any further information or advice on any matter covered within this article, please contact the author.
Comments

Add a Comment

Log in or sign up to post a comment

Testimonials
What I enjoyed most about Property School was the comprehensive coverage of all angles related to property investment. The speakers were highly professional. - Stephen Fagan - September 2017
We can help
Here's how

GRA logo

Gilligan Rowe and Associates is a chartered accounting firm specialising in property, asset planning, legal structures, taxation and compliance.

We help new, small and medium property investors become long-term successful investors through our education programmes and property portfolio planning advice. With our deep knowledge and experience, we have assisted hundreds of clients build wealth through property investment.

Learn More
GRA Senior Partners
TOP